BETA
This is a BETA experience. You may opt-out by clicking here

More From Forbes

Edit Story

11 Terrible CRM Systems For Your Company

Following
This article is more than 10 years old.

Thinking of getting a Customer Relationship Management (CRM) application?  Below, I’ve described 11 terrible ones.  Sure, they are all popular, affordable and mature.  In fact, my company (full disclosure) sells and services five of them (Salesforce, GoldMine, Microsoft Dynamics CRM, ZohoCRM and Nimble).  And given their features and functionality you’d think they’d be great tools for so many small and medium sized companies.  But they’re not.  They are all terrible.

Salesforce.com is arguably the most well known of these applications.  And deservedly so.  The company pretty much invented cloud-based CRM and remains committed to its future.  Like the products listed below, Salesforce.com offers sales, marketing and service management capabilities to its small and (very) large customers.  The application is only available through the cloud and can range in price from $60 to $125 per month per user for the typical corporate version (although pricing can be less for very basic features or more depending on the added modules purchased).

GoldMine is more of an advanced contact manager than a full blown customer relationship management system.  But the aging product has been around for many years and still maintains a large following.  The software, which is on-premise only, is targeted primarily at groups of 5-25 users and costs about $3,000 for a five concurrent user system.  It is quick to setup, easy to use, synchronizes with Outlook and QuickBooks and sold through a national network of resellers and partners.

Microsoft Dynamics CRM is available in both on-premise (approximately $1,100 per named user and approximately $5,000 for the server software) or via the cloud at $44/month/user.  Dynamics CRM has grown significantly over the past few years, mainly because of its ease of use and seamless integration with all-things-Microsoft, from Outlook and Office to Sharepoint and its other business applications like Dynamics GP.  Dynamics is extremely customizable, scalable to larger, enterprise-size workgroups and serviced through Microsoft’s partner channel.

ACT!  Yes, it’s still there, even though it’s been recently sold by Sage to Swiftpage.  ACT! excels mostly with very small user groups but I’ve seen it used effectively with dozens of people at a time.  Many salespeople I know love it.   Priced similar to GoldMine above, ACT! is primarily an on-premise application with cloud-based options.

ZohoCRM is a relative newcomer to the CRM marketplace and has found a huge niche as (I like to call it) the “poor man’s Salesforce.com.”  ZohoCRM is just one of a suite of business applications from Zoho that include productivity, office, project management, invoicing and recruiting.  The Enterprise version of ZohoCRM runs $35/month/user but a free, stripped down version is available for less than three users.  ZohoCRM is completely cloud based, integrates with many Google Apps and syncs with QuickBooks and Outlook.  There is also a growing army of Zoho developers and partners with tools to further customize and integrate the product with other systems.

Nimble is a web-based application that provides most of the common functionality you would expect from today’s CRM systems with the added specialty of deeply integrating with social media services like Facebook, Twitter and LinkedIn.  Nimble is also a relative newcomer to the market but has gained significant traction over the past two years.  For only $15/user/month Nimble will let your users listen in on social media activity to identify opportunities and provide all the activity, communication and contact management tools to make sure those opportunities do not fall through the cracks.  Nimble also has a growing number of third party apps for more advanced tasks.

Insightly claims more than 300,000 users of its powerful small business, cloud based CRM application.  Like ZohoCRM, Insightly offers a basic free version for up to three users and then runs up to $99 per month for its deluxe plan which allows up to 40 users to take advantage of its advanced CRM and project management capabilities.  What sets Insightly apart is its deep integration with Google’s products like Google Apps, Gmail and Google Drive (although there is integration with Office 365 and Outlook 2013 too).

SugarCRM has been a popular choice for many small and medium sized businesses over the past few years, mainly because the company offers both affordable on-premise and cloud based versions and makes its source code available for those intrepid enough to want to build advanced customizations and deeper integration with their own systems.  SugarCRM can run from $35 to $100 per user per month or you can just buy it outright.  The company has steadily built a good partner channel for implementation and prides itself on its industry specific editions.  Integration with Lotus Notes has also been a unique feature.

Highrise CRM is a good choice for those who already benefitting from the great project management features of its sister product Basecamp and want to expand into sales and marketing management.  Also made by 37Signals (the makers of Basecamp), Highrise’s cloud based pricing ranges from $24/month for 6 users to $99/month for 40 users.

Sage CRM can be rented online for $39/user/month or purchased outright so that corporate users can benefit from its sales, case, campaign and email management functionality.  Sage CRM is a mature, powerful CRM application that any user of a Sage product (i.e. Sage 100 – formerly MAS or Sage 300 – formerly Accpac) should seriously consider.  Sage has a strong partner network and deep financial resources.

NetSuite is a good choice for those with a big budget and the desire for a fully integrated, cloud based business system that will not only provide CRM functionality but also handle everything from purchase order management to inventory control, e-commerce activity and human resources.  NetSuite is powerful, mature and sold through a network of partners.  It comes in many industry specific versions and provides tools for developers to further customize.  Pricing is available from their resellers but many of the clients I know who are using the product are paying anywhere from $1,500 to $3,500 per month for the use of its many modules for their users.

Each and every one of these applications are excellent in their own way and I wish I had enough internal resources to offer them all to my clients.  But unfortunately they are all also terrible. Why?  It’s not why.  It’s when.

They are terrible when they are not implemented the right way.   They are terrible when companies don’t appreciate that all of these magical applications are nothing but databases and don’t put the right processes in place to ensure that all interactions are entered into this database so that the data can be properly used for further sales, marketing and service interactions.  They are terrible when companies don’t assign strong administrators, or cut corners on training or try to do too much at one time.  They are terrible when senior managers don’t pay the attention needed to make these systems successful and instead cave in to the complaints made by lower level employees who don’t want to do the extra work.  These applications are terrible when managers don’t insist on the reports they should be using, don’t enforce rules for entering new opportunities and don’t commit to long-term, consistent and repetitive drip-marketing and communication campaigns using the information maintained by their CRM system to keep their prospects informed and their customers close.

Yes, these CRM systems are terrible.  As terrible as an automatic rifle given to a child or a nine-iron handed to a monkey.  But placed in the right hands, like a soldier or a professional golfer, a CRM system (like the popular ones listed above) can be a powerful tool for growing a company’s profits and increasing its value.  So is your CRM system terrible?  Or is it you?

Besides Forbes, Gene Marks writes weekly for The New York Times and Inc.com.